fix.mom

Home appliance guide

Repair or Replace? Appliance Lifespan and Repair Cost Calculator

A broken fridge, washer or water heater forces a fast decision. This page gives you the typical service life of each major appliance, the common 50% rule and its limits, and a calculator that shows its reasoning, so you can decide with numbers instead of guesses.

Repair or replace calculator

Pick the appliance type. The typical lifespan fills in from the NAHB 2007 study, and you can change it. Then enter the age of your unit, the repair quote and the price of a comparable new unit. Yearly energy savings are optional.

How it works: share of life used = age ÷ typical lifespan. Repair-to-replace ratio = repair quote ÷ net cost of replacing. If you enter yearly energy savings, the net cost of replacing is the new price minus those savings over the years your old unit would likely still run (at least 1 year). The verdict follows the 50% rule and the share-of-life check described below: a unit with 75% or more of its life used and a repair of 30% or more of replacing gets a lean-replace verdict.

How long major appliances last

Two widely quoted references give typical service life for home appliances. The NAHB Study of Life Expectancy of Home Components (February 2007) gives one average figure per item, based on industry sources. The InterNACHI Standard Estimated Life Expectancy Chart for Homes gives ranges and says they are guidelines, not guarantees.

ApplianceNAHB 2007 (years)InterNACHI chart (years)
Refrigerator (standard)139–13
Refrigerator (compact)9—
Clothes washer105–15
Clothes dryer (electric or gas)1313
Dishwasher99
Water heater, electric (tank)116–12 (conventional)
Water heater, gas (tank)106–12 (conventional)
Water heater, tankless20+10
Furnace, gas warm-air1815–25 (furnace)
Range, gas1515–17
Range, electric1313–15
Microwave oven99

A dash means the chart does not list that item. The InterNACHI chart does not split tank water heaters by fuel, so the same range appears for both.

These are averages. NAHB notes that the life of a typical appliance depends to a great extent on the use it receives, and that people often replace appliances before they wear out because styling, technology and preferences change. A washer in a family of six works much harder than one in a single-person home. Hard water shortens the life of water heaters and dishwashers. Regular care, such as cleaning condenser coils, lint ducts and filters, helps a unit reach or pass the average.

The 50% rule and where it falls short

The 50% rule is a common rule of thumb used by many technicians and consumer guides. In its usual form it says:

The rule is useful because it is quick. It also has clear limits.

It ignores what comes next

A $300 repair on a 12-year-old refrigerator may pass the 50% test, but the compressor, fans and controls are all old. One repair now can lead to another next year. The share-of-life check in the calculator helps you see this risk.

It ignores the price gap between models

A basic replacement and a premium replacement can differ by thousands of dollars. Compare the repair quote with a new unit of similar size and features, not with the cheapest or most expensive model in the store.

It ignores running costs and comfort

An old unit can cost more to run every month. A new unit may also be quieter or hold temperature better. Enter yearly energy savings in the calculator if you have a fair estimate.

It ignores small, cheap fixes

A door gasket, a drain pump filter or an igniter is often a small part. A low-cost fix can make sense even on an old unit, as long as the rest of the appliance is in good shape.

Energy savings from replacing old units

Energy use is a real but modest factor for most appliances. ENERGY STAR gives these figures on its product pages:

Your savings depend on your electricity or gas rate, how much you use the appliance and how old the current unit is. Do not count savings twice: if you keep the old unit running in the garage as a second fridge, you lose most of the benefit. If you replace a refrigerator, ask the retailer or your utility about recycling the old one.

When not to do it yourself

Stop and call a qualified technician for any of the cases below. Unplug the unit or turn off its breaker, and turn off the gas supply if you smell gas.

Simple checks before you call a technician

Many service calls end with a reset or a cleaned filter. Try these safe checks first:

When you call, give the brand, the model and serial number, the age of the unit and the error code. This helps the technician bring the right part.

Warranty and parts availability

Before you pay for a repair, check whether the unit is still covered. Look at the manufacturer warranty in the manual, any extended plan you bought, and the coverage of the credit card you used. Some manufacturers give longer coverage on specific parts such as compressors or motors than on the rest of the unit.

Ask the technician whether the part is in stock and how long it will take to arrive. For older or discontinued models, parts can be slow, expensive or no longer made. A long wait for a refrigerator or water heater part can tip the decision toward replacement. Ask for a written quote that splits parts and labor, and ask whether the repair has its own warranty.

Frequently asked questions

What is the 50% rule for appliance repair?

The 50% rule is a rule of thumb, not a law or an industry standard. It says to replace an appliance when the repair costs more than about half the price of a comparable new unit, and to be extra careful when the appliance is already past the first half of its typical service life. It is a quick filter, not a final answer.

How long does a refrigerator usually last?

The NAHB Study of Life Expectancy of Home Components (2007) lists 13 years for a standard refrigerator and 9 years for a compact one. The InterNACHI Standard Estimated Life Expectancy Chart for Homes gives a range of 9 to 13 years. Real life depends on use, upkeep and the model.

Is it worth replacing an old refrigerator to save energy?

It can help, but energy savings alone rarely pay for a new refrigerator quickly. ENERGY STAR says refrigerators over 15 years old could cost about $95 per year to run, and that recycling an old unit and buying a certified model can save about $150 over the 12-year lifetime of the product. Treat savings as one input, next to repair cost and age.

Can I repair a gas appliance or a refrigerator's sealed system myself?

Leave gas lines, gas valves and burners, refrigerant circuits and 240-volt wiring to a qualified technician. Under US EPA Section 608 rules, technicians who maintain, service, repair or dispose of equipment that could release ozone-depleting refrigerants must be certified. Gas and high-voltage faults can cause fire, carbon monoxide exposure or electric shock.

What should I check before I call a repair technician?

Check that the unit has power and that the breaker or fuse is good, that a gas supply valve is open, that filters and lint screens are clean, that drain hoses and filters are not blocked, and that the door seals and door switches work. Write down any error code. These checks often fix the problem or make the service call shorter.

Does the calculator tell me exactly what to do?

No. The calculator applies the common 50% rule and a share-of-life check to the numbers you enter and shows its reasoning. Warranty coverage, parts availability, safety and how much you like the unit can change the right choice.

Sources

We checked each figure on this page against these sources in November 2026. Sources are named in plain text.

Last reviewed November 2026. This page is general information, not professional advice. Prices and savings vary by location and model.